← Back
Crime Junkie May 16, 2026 2m

A Tourist Reported a Strange Encounter... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

Summary

The transcript details an unusual tip in the disappearance of Melissa, involving a horse-riding man named Rick Valerio who was seen near a church in Taos, New Mexico, apparently distraught and discussing a decapitated body. A tourist photographed Valerio and later connected him to Melissa's missing person case, leading investigators to interview him, though they ultimately dismissed his involvement as a fabricated story seeking attention. The key takeaway underscores the complexities of investigating missing person cases and the challenges of evaluating potential leads that may seem credible but lack substantive evidence.

View original episode ↗