← Back
Crime Junkie March 31, 2026 27s

Should've the Key Evidence Never Been Used?? #maryyoder #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts

Summary

The transcript discusses the legal proceedings surrounding Katie's trial for the murder of Mary Yoder, highlighting the initial mistrial and subsequent conviction for first-degree manslaughter. After a first trial ended with a deadlocked jury leaning towards acquittal, prosecutors successfully retried Katie in 2017, resulting in a 23-year sentence. The case remains controversial, with lingering questions about the validity of the key evidence used to secure her conviction.

View original episode ↗