← Back
Crime Junkie March 24, 2026 1m

Was She Framed… or Caught? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #maryyoder

Summary

The transcript details a complex murder investigation involving Kaitlyn Conley, Adam's ex-girlfriend, who was initially convicted of poisoning Mary Ann Otterness with colchicine. Digital evidence, including an email account, Wi-Fi access, and DNA on the poison bottle, initially implicated Conley, but her conviction was later overturned in 2025, leaving the case technically unsolved and the victim's family divided. The key takeaway is that technological and forensic evidence can be both revealing and misleading, highlighting the intricate nature of modern criminal investigations.

View original episode ↗