The Rural Church is More Hopeful Than You Think
Read full transcript 26 segments
-
Lifeway surveyed over Lifeway surveyed over a thousand rural a thousand rural a thousand rural pastors about their pastors about their pastors about their ministry, and 88% said they ministry, and 88% said they ministry, and 88% said they expect their expect their expect their church to become church to become church to become stronger within a stronger within a stronger within a decade. decade. decade. 88%. 88%. 88%. This is a lot of optimism This is a lot of optimism This is a lot of optimism from people who from people who from people who work work work directly and directly and directly and know how difficult it know how difficult it know how difficult it often is to often is to often is to work in work in work in small, rural small, rural small, rural churches. So today churches. So today churches. So today we will look at we will look at we will look at the findings. Let's the findings. Let's the findings. Let's dive into this. Well, dive into this. Well, dive into this. Well, hello and hello and hello and welcome to the Pro Church welcome to the Pro Church welcome to the Pro Church Tools Show. We are here to Tools Show. We are here to Tools Show. We are here to help you and your help you and your help you and your church church church navigate the navigate the navigate the biggest biggest biggest communications communications communications shift in 500 years. shift in 500 years. shift in 500 years. I'm Brady Shearer, your I'm Brady Shearer, your I'm Brady Shearer, your host. I was joined, as host. I was joined, as host. I was joined, as usual, by usual, by usual, by my co-host. We my co-host. We my co-host. We call him the call him the call him the village village village reverend. reverend. reverend. This is Alexander Mills. This is Alexander Mills. This is Alexander Mills. Hello, hello. Hello, hello. Hello, hello. Today we Today we Today we bring you some bring you some bring you some unexpected findings unexpected findings , at least that's what I would , at least that's what I would , at least that's what I would call them, from Lifeway. 88% of call them, from Lifeway. 88% of rural pastors rural pastors rural pastors expect their expect their expect their church to be church to be church to be stronger in 10 stronger in 10 stronger in 10 years. This is not me years. This is not me years. This is not me commenting on the state of the church commenting on the state of the church commenting on the state of the church in rural in rural in rural America, but America, but America, but sitting across from the sitting across from the sitting across from the pastor of a church in pastor of a church in pastor of a church in rural rural rural Canada, which is as Canada, which is as close to close to rural America as possible, because rural America as possible, because rural America as possible, because we are in we are in we are in Niagara, Ontario, Niagara, Ontario, Niagara, Ontario, Canada. So I'm not Canada. So I'm not Canada. So I'm not going to do the going to do the going to do the usual thing where I usual thing where I usual thing where I talk a lot talk a lot talk a lot about it. First, I about it. First, I about it. First, I want to pass this on to you. Is want to pass this on to you. Is this an unexpected this an unexpected discovery from your discovery from your discovery from your perspective, or am I simply perspective, or am I simply perspective, or am I simply imposing imposing imposing certain feelings on the village church certain feelings on the village church certain feelings on the village church that don't belong there? An that don't belong there? An interesting question for interesting question for several reasons.
-
several reasons. several reasons. It wasn't in It wasn't in It wasn't in the notes. Got it. The the notes. Got it. The the notes. Got it. The first question, the first first question, the first first question, the first reason—it's simply the reason—it's simply the reason—it's simply the idea of defining idea of defining idea of defining rural. What rural. What rural. What does rural mean? I does rural mean? I does rural mean? I define my church define my church define my church as a rural church. as a rural church. as a rural church. The reason I The reason I The reason I define my church this way is define my church this way is because it is because it is located outside the located outside the located outside the city. It is city. It is city. It is located on what located on what located on what I call a I call a I call a rural area. rural area. rural area. You know, it's literally You know, it's literally You know, it's literally called a concession called a concession , concession seven. What is this , concession seven. What is this , concession seven. What is this ? ? ? I love the concession. I love the concession. I love the concession. And you look And you look And you look around, and it's around, and it's around, and it's mostly mostly mostly farmland farmland farmland , and there are no , and there are no , and there are no sidewalks. You don't sidewalks. You don't sidewalks. You don't like that there is no like that there is no like that there is no traffic. You don't traffic. You don't traffic. You don't pass by our pass by our pass by our church. A church. A giant Mack Mansion is being built right across the street. I heard Mansion is being built right across the street. I heard Mansion is being built right across the street. I heard you like it, it's you like it, it's you like it, it's very famous. very famous. very famous. We We We were just a few weeks ago were just a few weeks ago were just a few weeks ago after the service and were after the service and were after the service and were grieving about it. Um, are grieving about it. Um, are grieving about it. Um, are you standing there on the lawn you standing there on the lawn you standing there on the lawn in front of the house because in front of the house because in front of the house because he's the one he's the one he's the one building it? building it? building it? I don't. I don't. I don't. It's me. You used to be able to It's me. You used to be able to see St. see St. David's Bench from there and all the way across the David's Bench from there and all the way across the David's Bench from there and all the way across the lake, you could lake, you could lake, you could see Toronto from there, see Toronto from there, see Toronto from there, but now all you see is but now all you see is but now all you see is this Mac Mansion this Mac Mansion this Mac Mansion that's under construction. that's under construction. that's under construction. I see him. From your I see him. From your I see him. From your backyard. backyard. backyard. Yes. And I also Yes. And I also Yes. And I also define our church define our church define our church as rural because as rural because as rural because historically I know historically I know historically I know people who belonged people who belonged people who belonged to our church. to our church.
-
Many of them were Many of them were farmers and, um, had lived farmers and, um, had lived farmers and, um, had lived in this place as long as they in this place as long as they in this place as long as they had. They have had. They have had. They have this sense of this sense of this sense of rootedness and rootedness and rootedness and place, and that in a place, and that in a place, and that in a way defines way defines way defines rural life, rural life, rural life, country life, for me. Now country life, for me. Now , the second reason why , the second reason why , the second reason why this is interesting to me is this is interesting to me is this is interesting to me is because because because your church your church your church is one is one is one block from here. block from here. block from here. That's why I built the That's why I built the That's why I built the Mac Mansion right there, Mac Mansion right there, Mac Mansion right there, because it's so close to because it's so close to because it's so close to you and my church. you and my church. you and my church. And I wonder if there is a And I wonder if there is a Holiday Inn? Holiday Inn? Would Central define Would Central define Would Central define its identity as a its identity as a its identity as a rural church? You rural church? You rural church? You came from the city. Uh, came from the city. Uh, came from the city. Uh, Central has always been a Central has always been a Central has always been a city church city church city church as long as I've lived and as long as I've lived and as long as I've lived and prayed in Niagara. prayed in Niagara. prayed in Niagara. Interesting. Interesting. Interesting. But when you guys But when you guys But when you guys built your new built your new built your new building and moved in, building and moved in, building and moved in, you moved out of the city you moved out of the city you moved out of the city and moved in, I guess, and moved in, I guess, and moved in, I guess, to our backyard, but to our backyard, but to our backyard, but when I think of Central, when I think of Central, when I think of Central, I don't think of a I don't think of a I don't think of a country church. country church. country church. I think we I think we I think we need to eliminate the need to eliminate the need to eliminate the big churches. There are about a big churches. There are about a big churches. There are about a few thousand of us, which is few thousand of us, which is few thousand of us, which is quite a lot for quite a lot for quite a lot for Canada. Canada. Canada. Yes. Yes. Yes. Because people Because people Because people come to us. come to us. come to us. The reason we The reason we The reason we moved our moved our moved our church was church was church was because we always because we always because we always considered ourselves the church considered ourselves the church considered ourselves the church for Niagara, the region. for Niagara, the region. for Niagara, the region. We were in St.
-
We were in St. Catharines, which is Catharines, which is Catharines, which is about one about one about one side. So as we side. So as we side. So as we expanded because we expanded because we expanded because we grew, we thought, grew, we thought, grew, we thought, “Okay, now is the “Okay, now is the “Okay, now is the time to move time to move time to move downtown, which is to downtown, which is to downtown, which is to our church, which is our church, which is our church, which is conveniently located conveniently located conveniently located 5 minutes from my 5 minutes from my 5 minutes from my house. No, not to the Mac house. No, not to the Mac Mansion, where I Mansion, where I Mansion, where I actually live. Which makes actually live. Which makes actually live. Which makes me very happy. They me very happy. They me very happy. They say, "We're say, "We're say, "We're moving." I moving." I moving." I thought, "Where to?" They thought, "Where to?" They thought, "Where to?" They say, "Here." I say, "Here." I say, "Here." I thought, "Really?" " thought, "Really?" " Great." Great." Great." So to your question So to your question , does this finding surprise me , does this finding surprise me , does this finding surprise me ? Is it any ? Is it any ? Is it any surprise that 88%...as well as the surprise that 88%...as well as the surprise that 88%...as well as the vast vast vast majority of rural majority of rural majority of rural pastors, of pastors, of pastors, of which I am one... which I am one... which I am one... Yes, Yes, Yes, expect their expect their expect their church to be church to be church to be stronger in 10 stronger in 10 stronger in 10 years. Yes, this is years. Yes, this is years. Yes, this is unexpected for me unexpected for me unexpected for me because I have always lived in because I have always lived in because I have always lived in Niagara. So if you Niagara. So if you Niagara. So if you zoom out and zoom out and zoom out and look at look at look at Niagara from 30,000 Niagara from 30,000 Niagara from 30,000 feet on a map, I know I feet on a map, I know I could point out to could point out to could point out to you all the rural you all the rural you all the rural churches in Niagara that have churches in Niagara that have churches in Niagara that have been around for, been around for, been around for, you know, 35 years. Our you know, 35 years. Our you know, 35 years. Our church is about to church is about to church is about to celebrate 45 years. And celebrate 45 years. And celebrate 45 years. And I see them all on this I see them all on this I see them all on this map. I see 75 people map. I see 75 people map. I see 75 people here, 115 here, 200 here, 45 here, 115 here, 200 here, 45 here, 115 here, 200 here, 45 here, 15 here. I know here, 15 here. I know here, 15 here. I know many of these many of these many of these pastors. And when I pastors. And when I pastors. And when I think about these congregations, think about these congregations, think about these congregations, including mine, I including mine, I including mine, I think about these think about these think about these pastors, including pastors, including pastors, including mine, I would be mine, I would be mine, I would be surprised if you surprised if you surprised if you pulled us out to pulled us out to pulled us out to get this number get this number get this number that we would all that we would all that we would all hope for...
-
hope for... hope for... Mmm...um... Mmm...um... Mmm...um... it's...Our church will be it's...Our church will be it's...Our church will be stronger in 10 stronger in 10 stronger in 10 years because I know what years because I know what years because I know what seems like a unique seems like a unique seems like a unique challenge, pressure and challenge, pressure and challenge, pressure and obstacle. This is not obstacle. This is not obstacle. This is not to say that urban to say that urban to say that urban churches or other types of churches or other types of churches or other types of churches don't have their churches don't have their churches don't have their own, but I know own, but I know own, but I know what unique what unique what unique obstacles we have. And in 2026, obstacles we have. And in 2026, obstacles we have. And in 2026, those hurdles seem, in some those hurdles seem, in some those hurdles seem, in some ways, ways, ways, higher than ever, higher than ever, higher than ever, more challenging than ever more challenging than ever . Hmm, but . Hmm, but . Hmm, but of course we have of course we have of course we have hope, right? Uh, hope, right? Uh, hope, right? Uh, if we didn't have if we didn't have if we didn't have hope, we wouldn't be hope, we wouldn't be hope, we wouldn't be doing what we're doing. doing what we're doing. doing what we're doing. Uh, I think that's Uh, I think that's Uh, I think that's probably probably probably factored into this factored into this factored into this number as well. But yes, that number as well. But yes, that number as well. But yes, that number seems number seems number seems high. I hope it's high. I hope it's high. I hope it's high. high. high. And this number doesn't exist on its own And this number doesn't exist on its own And this number doesn't exist on its own , according , according , according to the LifeWay report. Yes, 88% of to the LifeWay report. Yes, 88% of rural pastors rural pastors rural pastors expect their expect their expect their church to be church to be church to be stronger in a stronger in a stronger in a decade. decade. decade. At the same time, 60% At the same time, 60% identify that identify that identify that developing and developing and empowering leaders empowering leaders is a challenge. 50% said: is a challenge. 50% said: is a challenge. 50% said: "You know, we see "You know, we see "You know, we see a lot of resistance to change." a lot of resistance to change." a lot of resistance to change." “44% acknowledge “44% acknowledge “44% acknowledge financial constraints. financial constraints. So optimism can So optimism can exist alongside what exist alongside what exist alongside what you describe as an you describe as an you describe as an awareness of the awareness of the awareness of the reality of the church in reality of the church in reality of the church in rural areas rural areas . So let's . So let's . So let's get to the heart of this get to the heart of this get to the heart of this 88% hope. Where does it 88% hope. Where does it 88% hope. Where does it come from? Well, in this come from? Well, in this come from? Well, in this report it was described report it was described report it was described as a scoreboard for as a scoreboard for as a scoreboard for these churches, perhaps these churches, perhaps these churches, perhaps more than what the more than what the more than what the church can church can church can imagine, well, it's imagine, well, it's imagine, well, it's attendance. It's, attendance. It's, attendance. It's, you know, buttocks and you know, buttocks and you know, buttocks and seats. Pastors seats. Pastors seats. Pastors identified these as identified these as identified these as signs of successful signs of successful signs of successful rural ministry.
-
rural ministry. rural ministry. So when you hear So when you hear So when you hear things like that, think things like that, think things like that, think of the pastor who of the pastor who of the pastor who thinks, “We’ll be thinks, “We’ll be thinks, “We’ll be stronger in 10 stronger in 10 stronger in 10 years because that’s how years because that’s how years because that’s how they measure it they measure it .” “Church members .” “Church members .” “Church members care about each care about each care about each other. 98% said it was a other. 98% said it was a other. 98% said it was a successful rural successful rural successful rural ministry. Healing of ministry. Healing of ministry. Healing of broken relationships – 94 broken relationships – 94 %. Church members are %. Church members are %. Church members are constantly present, constantly present, constantly present, as if they are an active as if they are an active as if they are an active part of the community – 94%. part of the community – 94%. part of the community – 94%. Church members take Church members take Church members take on leadership on leadership on leadership positions – 93%. New positions – 93%. New positions – 93%. New commitments to commitments to commitments to Christ–93%. Where are the 7% Christ–93%. Where are the 7% Christ–93%. Where are the 7% who said, "You who said, "You who said, "You have decided to follow have decided to follow have decided to follow Jesus?" Well, we did Jesus?" Well, we did Jesus?" Well, we did n't do anything n't do anything n't do anything right." "I'm right." "I'm right." "I'm curious." Becoming a curious." Becoming a curious." Becoming a trusted part of trusted part of trusted part of city life – 88%, and city life – 88%, and city life – 88%, and then the growth then the growth then the growth in attendance in attendance in attendance relatively decreased relatively decreased relatively decreased to 77%. So I think that's to 77%. So I think that's to 77%. So I think that's really interesting, and really interesting, and really interesting, and it relates to your it relates to your it relates to your discussion about the people discussion about the people discussion about the people who come to this who come to this who come to this church, they lived in church, they lived in church, they lived in this region. They are this region. They are this region. They are part of this part of this part of this region. They region. They region. They literally have roots literally have roots literally have roots as farmers, the ones as farmers, the ones as farmers, the ones you were talking about. you were talking about. you were talking about. Increased Increased Increased attendance – 77% of attendance – 77% of these rural these rural these rural pastors say pastors say pastors say this is a sign of success. Up 11 this is a sign of success. Up 11 this is a sign of success. Up 11 points, 88% points, 88% are simply a trusted are simply a trusted are simply a trusted part of city life.
-
part of city life. Attendance growth is Attendance growth is still important to still important to still important to most of these most of these most of these pastors, but it was pastors, but it was pastors, but it was the least frequently the least frequently the least frequently chosen metric of chosen metric of chosen metric of these seven. And I these seven. And I these seven. And I even think about your even think about your even think about your father, who father, who father, who was the pastor of was the pastor of Abundant Life for many years, and is Abundant Life for many years, and is Abundant Life for many years, and is now running for now running for now running for some city council. some city council. some city council. Right, right. Right, right. Right, right. So is this something a So is this something a So is this something a megachurch pastor would consider? megachurch pastor would consider? megachurch pastor would consider? Almost certainly not. Almost certainly not. Almost certainly not. The pastor of a rural The pastor of a rural The pastor of a rural church, so church, so church, so rooted in his rooted in his rooted in his town, so town, so town, so well known to everyone well known to everyone well known to everyone outside the church, says, “ outside the church, says, “ You know what?” I have contributed You know what?” I have contributed You know what?” I have contributed to this to this to this ministry. Can I ministry. Can I ministry. Can I also make a also make a also make a difference and be a difference and be a difference and be a light for Jesus and light for Jesus and light for Jesus and for this city in for this city in for this city in another political another political another political position? position? position? Hmm. There Hmm. There Hmm. There really is a really is a really is a sense of place, a sense of place, a sense of place, a sense of sense of sense of rootedness, in a village church that I rootedness, in a village church that I rootedness, in a village church that I felt. Of course, felt. Of course, felt. Of course, this is the only church this is the only church this is the only church I've ever pastored and the I've ever pastored and the I've ever pastored and the only church only church only church I've ever truly belonged to, I've ever truly belonged to, I've ever truly belonged to, but that doesn't mean but that doesn't mean but that doesn't mean I don't have a broader I don't have a broader I don't have a broader experience of what experience of what experience of what other church other church other church cultures are like. So I can cultures are like. So I can cultures are like. So I can talk a little bit about talk a little bit about talk a little bit about that both because of the nature of the that both because of the nature of the that both because of the nature of the work I do work I do work I do here at ProChurchTools and Nucleus, and here at ProChurchTools and Nucleus, and here at ProChurchTools and Nucleus, and because of my other because of my other because of my other inter-ministerial inter-ministerial inter-ministerial relationships and experiences in relationships and experiences in relationships and experiences in church culture.
-
church culture. church culture. The sense of The sense of The sense of rootedness that I rootedness that I rootedness that I feel in these feel in these feel in these rural churches, where rural churches, where rural churches, where people are mostly...I people are mostly...I people are mostly...I think about it, as we think about it, as we think about it, as we have this conversation, I have this conversation, I have this conversation, I see people who see people who see people who belong to my belong to my belong to my church. And I just church. And I just church. And I just know that most of know that most of know that most of them just lived there and them just lived there and them just lived there and intend to intend to intend to die there. And this is die there. And this is die there. And this is different from the different from the different from the fleeting fleeting fleeting nature of city life nature of city life that sometimes occurs. And that sometimes occurs. And that sometimes occurs. And we can talk we can talk we can talk about globalization and about globalization and about globalization and so on, but that's how so on, but that's how so on, but that's how cities move, cities move, cities move, right? And a megachurch. right? And a megachurch. right? And a megachurch. We've talked so much We've talked so much We've talked so much about about about small church small church small church versus megachurch, not to versus megachurch, not to versus megachurch, not to mention good mention good mention good versus bad, but versus bad, but versus bad, but just the dynamic of just the dynamic of just the dynamic of both over the last both over the last both over the last few weeks, a few few weeks, a few few weeks, a few episodes. And it's episodes. And it's episodes. And it's okay to recognize that okay to recognize that okay to recognize that the types of communities are very the types of communities are very the types of communities are very different. And in big different. And in big different. And in big churches, you get churches, you get churches, you get something like, "Oh, something like, "Oh, something like, "Oh, yeah, we moved to a yeah, we moved to a yeah, we moved to a city, and, oh, we city, and, oh, we city, and, oh, we moved to the moved to the moved to the next city next city next city because of work, and because of work, and because of work, and we're actually we're actually we're actually going to work going to work going to work from home." So now we are from home." So now we are from home." So now we are moving to moving to moving to this city because we this city because we this city because we always wanted to always wanted to always wanted to live there. It's just the live there. It's just the live there. It's just the nature of city nature of city nature of city life. But rural life. But rural life. But rural life is like working life is like working life is like working on this farm, because my on this farm, because my on this farm, because my grandfather worked on this grandfather worked on this grandfather worked on this farm, because he farm, because he farm, because he moved here from moved here from moved here from Paraguay, and he knew Paraguay, and he knew Paraguay, and he knew how to how to how to farm, so we farm, so we farm, so we landed right landed right landed right here, and my children now here, and my children now here, and my children now work on the farm.
-
work on the farm. work on the farm. So, as long as this farm is So, as long as this farm is So, as long as this farm is here, we will be here. And here, we will be here. And here, we will be here. And the church is the church is the church is right down the street, and that's why right down the street, and that's why right down the street, and that's why we go we go we go to this church. And so to this church. And so , yes, there's this sense of , yes, there's this sense of , yes, there's this sense of place and place and place and rootedness, which, as rootedness, which, as rootedness, which, as you said, is the you said, is the you said, is the reason why reason why reason why my dad is running my dad is running my dad is running for city council, not for city council, not for city council, not because he's a politician, because he's a politician, because he's a politician, but because he's always but because he's always but because he's always lived in Niagara-on-the-Lake. lived in Niagara-on-the-Lake. lived in Niagara-on-the-Lake. And when people in the community And when people in the community And when people in the community think of Rick think of Rick think of Rick Mills, they think Mills, they think Mills, they think of Niagara-on-the-Lake. And of Niagara-on-the-Lake. And of Niagara-on-the-Lake. And so he just so he just so he just feels like he can feels like he can feels like he can bring a non-disturbing bring a non-disturbing bring a non-disturbing presence to, you know presence to, you know , local government. , local government. , local government. But, yeah, I think that's But, yeah, I think that's But, yeah, I think that's just part of just part of just part of , you know, the apostle , you know, the apostle , you know, the apostle Paul talks about this Paul talks about this Paul talks about this , about some , about some , about some communities being hands, communities being hands, communities being hands, some being feet, and some being some being feet, and some being ears, noses, and this, and that. ears, noses, and this, and that. ears, noses, and this, and that. And when I think about the And when I think about the And when I think about the different types of churches, different types of churches, different types of churches, rural versus rural versus rural versus urban, these versus those, urban, these versus those, urban, these versus those, they all play they all play they all play such a vital such a vital such a vital role. And that's the role of the role. And that's the role of the role. And that's the role of the rural church, I rural church, I rural church, I think, it's a different think, it's a different think, it's a different type of community, where when type of community, where when type of community, where when we think about the we think about the we think about the scorecard, the scorecard, the scorecard, the pastor thinks about our pastor thinks about our pastor thinks about our church, like, what is a church, like, what is a church, like, what is a stronger stronger stronger community? What will community? What will community? What will my church be like in 10 my church be like in 10 my church be like in 10 years? How does she years? How does she years? How does she look stronger?
-
look stronger? look stronger? This is, oh, I know this This is, oh, I know this This is, oh, I know this interpersonal interpersonal interpersonal conflict between these conflict between these conflict between these two people, and I see that I two people, and I see that I have hope that if have hope that if have hope that if they they they continue to continue to continue to stay stay stay indigenous here, we can indigenous here, we can indigenous here, we can fix it. We will fix it. We will fix it. We will practice practice practice forgiveness and we forgiveness and we forgiveness and we will see reconciliation. will see reconciliation. will see reconciliation. So, this is my So, this is my So, this is my scorecard. This is how I scorecard. This is how I scorecard. This is how I see the strength of our see the strength of our see the strength of our community growing community growing community growing from now and into the from now and into the from now and into the next 10 years, next 10 years, next 10 years, rather than, perhaps, by rather than, perhaps, by rather than, perhaps, by some other some other some other metric, churches of metric, churches of metric, churches of other shapes and sizes would other shapes and sizes would other shapes and sizes would have higher ratings, have higher ratings, have higher ratings, perhaps. What you perhaps. What you perhaps. What you also describe is also describe is also describe is simply being aware simply being aware simply being aware and present in and present in and present in people's lives. And the people's lives. And the people's lives. And the more the more the more the church grows, the more church grows, the more church grows, the more people are present in it people are present in it , the less you become , the less you become , the less you become humanly capable of humanly capable of humanly capable of being involved in the being involved in the being involved in the life of each person. life of each person. I am not a pastor. I I am not a pastor. I founded this company, founded this company, founded this company, ProChurchTools, in 2014. ProChurchTools, in 2014. ProChurchTools, in 2014. I was 23 years old. It I was 23 years old. It I was 23 years old. It existed several existed several existed several years before that. That's years before that. That's years before that. That's when the government declared that when the government declared that when the government declared that we existed as a we existed as a we existed as a company. So, company. So, company. So, let's say 12 let's say 12 let's say 12 years have passed. I remember, this years have passed. I remember, this years have passed. I remember, this was before we was before we was before we officially became officially became officially became a company, just me a company, just me a company, just me as a sole as a sole as a sole proprietor, the first proprietor, the first proprietor, the first church that church that church that signed up to signed up to signed up to give us money give us money give us money through the product. And I through the product. And I through the product. And I remember, because an remember, because an remember, because an hour after hour after hour after they signed up they signed up , they called , they called , they called me and said, "Yeah, me and said, "Yeah, me and said, "Yeah, this isn't for us.
-
this isn't for us. this isn't for us. Please refund us. Please refund us. Please refund us. " I " I " I called my mom and called my mom and called my mom and cried. cried. cried. Mmm. Mmm. Mmm. I remember how devastated it was I remember how devastated it was I remember how devastated it was . And a month later, . And a month later, another another church registered. And it was a church registered. And it was a church registered. And it was a church from church from church from Jacksonville. And I will Jacksonville. And I will Jacksonville. And I will always remember this always remember this always remember this church. First, church. First, church. First, because they are still my because they are still my because they are still my client, which is client, which is client, which is amazing. But also amazing. But also amazing. But also because it was the first because it was the first because it was the first church that church that ever... And every ever... And every ever... And every first customer that first customer that first customer that signed up, I signed up, I signed up, I remember. Churches are remember. Churches are remember. Churches are audited at audited at audited at churchchaos.com. They churchchaos.com. They churchchaos.com. They get an assessment of the get an assessment of the get an assessment of the chaos of their church. And chaos of their church. And chaos of their church. And I'll be like, "Oh, I'll be like, "Oh, I'll be like, "Oh, my God. "We made my God. "We made my God. "We made a video ad for a video ad for a video ad for this church about 12 this church about 12 this church about 12 years ago." And I years ago." And I years ago." And I will remember. And every will remember. And every will remember. And every registration registration registration meant something. So, if meant something. So, if meant something. So, if you are a church, and the data here you are a church, and the data here you are a church, and the data here shows that the average shows that the average shows that the average church reported church reported church reported five new five new five new commitments to commitments to commitments to Christ in the previous 12 Christ in the previous 12 Christ in the previous 12 months. 13% did not months. 13% did not months. 13% did not report report report any. These any. These any. These affections affections affections include children of include children of include children of church members, people church members, people church members, people from the wider community. from the wider community. from the wider community. Imagine a local Imagine a local Imagine a local community, a village community, a village community, a village church. A village church. A village church. A village church where five church where five church where five people dedicate people dedicate people dedicate their lives to Christ. their lives to Christ. their lives to Christ. Like, five people. Like, five people. Like, five people. Oho. I remember Oho. I remember Oho. I remember praying to God, " praying to God, " Lord, I Lord, I Lord, I only need three only need three only need three clients to make all this clients to make all this clients to make all this effort worth effort worth effort worth it." Like, I could it." Like, I could it." Like, I could replace my replace my replace my meager meager meager $1,200 a $1,200 a $1,200 a month church income because I worked as a month church income because I worked as a part-time media director. " part-time media director. " Only three churches are needed Only three churches are needed Only three churches are needed ." And I remember ." And I remember ." And I remember three churches that three churches that three churches that signed up.
-
signed up. signed up. We have We have We have three clients signing up today three clients signing up today three clients signing up today . . . Hmm. Hmm. Hmm. I will have no idea I will have no idea I will have no idea who they are. And that's just who they are. And that's just who they are. And that's just because of the difference in because of the difference in because of the difference in scale. Because, scale. Because, scale. Because, for example, right now I'm for example, right now I'm for example, right now I'm looking at something and looking at something and looking at something and thinking, "Well, if we thinking, "Well, if we thinking, "Well, if we want to grow by X%, want to grow by X%, want to grow by X%, we're going to need X we're going to need X we're going to need X things." And part of things." And part of things." And part of me seems to complain me seems to complain me seems to complain about it. But the other about it. But the other about it. But the other side of it is, "Well, we side of it is, "Well, we side of it is, "Well, we serve serve serve thousands and thousands of thousands and thousands of thousands and thousands of churches right now." And if I believe churches right now." And if I believe churches right now." And if I believe in the work we in the work we in the work we do, I would rather do, I would rather do, I would rather serve thousands of serve thousands of serve thousands of churches than three, churches than three, churches than three, even if I can't even if I can't even if I can't know them by name. And know them by name. And know them by name. And this shapes your this shapes your this shapes your attitude towards things. And that attitude towards things. And that attitude towards things. And that was the was the was the question. Do you believe question. Do you believe question. Do you believe that that that your church will be your church will be your church will be stronger in a decade? And if you stronger in a decade? And if you stronger in a decade? And if you can close your eyes can close your eyes can close your eyes and see five and see five and see five people who came to people who came to people who came to Christ, think, " Christ, think, " This is what I'm putting This is what I'm putting This is what I'm putting my hope in." my hope in." my hope in." Absolutely, that makes Absolutely, that makes Absolutely, that makes sense. And people who sense. And people who sense. And people who serve in these serve in these serve in these positions and have these positions and have these positions and have these abilities, I think abilities, I think abilities, I think one of our gifts one of our gifts one of our gifts is that we're is that we're is that we're going through these going through these going through these last few last few last few episodes and looking episodes and looking episodes and looking at what maybe there's at what maybe there's at what maybe there's this misnomer this misnomer this misnomer that megachurches that megachurches that megachurches don't teach at all, don't teach at all, don't teach at all, or larger churches or larger churches or larger churches don't teach at all. don't teach at all. don't teach at all. And maybe there is this And maybe there is this And maybe there is this misnomer misnomer misnomer regarding smaller churches. And regarding smaller churches. And regarding smaller churches. And that's why people that's why people that's why people like to go like to go like to go to bigger churches, and to bigger churches, and to bigger churches, and that's why people that's why people that's why people like to go like to go like to go to smaller churches, and to smaller churches, and to smaller churches, and they understand that they understand that they understand that each one of them is doing each one of them is doing each one of them is doing something incredible. And there's something incredible. And there's something incredible. And there's this weird, uh, this weird, uh, this weird, uh, parallel where now parallel where now parallel where now my church my church my church is like a is like a is like a football field away from football field away from football field away from Alex's church, and Alex's church, and Alex's church, and Alex is the pastor at a Alex is the pastor at a Alex is the pastor at a country church on the country church on the country church on the corner, and I'm at a megachurch corner, and I'm at a megachurch corner, and I'm at a megachurch on the other corner; and on the other corner; and on the other corner; and now we're sitting now we're sitting now we're sitting across from each other at across from each other at across from each other at this table, and we've this table, and we've this table, and we've been working at this been working at this been working at this company for 10 years, and it's almost company for 10 years, and it's almost company for 10 years, and it's almost like a representative like a representative like a representative feature of this discussion in
-
feature of this discussion in feature of this discussion in many ways. many ways. Hmm. But that's the difference But that's the difference between knowing about between knowing about between knowing about these five people and these five people and these five people and thinking, "I know that thinking, "I know that thinking, "I know that our work as a church our work as a church our work as a church has changed their lives has changed their lives has changed their lives by introducing them to by introducing them to by introducing them to Jesus or Jesus or Jesus or bringing them closer to bringing them closer to bringing them closer to Jesus than they were before." Jesus than they were before." Jesus than they were before." Of course, I'm Of course, I'm Of course, I'm looking forward to the looking forward to the looking forward to the next decade next decade . . . Yes, and in the rural Yes, and in the rural Yes, and in the rural church, which church, which church, which are more often than not smaller are more often than not smaller are more often than not smaller churches, we almost churches, we almost churches, we almost use them use them use them interchangeably, but that's interchangeably, but that's interchangeably, but that's just the nature of things. There are just the nature of things. There are just the nature of things. There are n't many n't many n't many rural megachurches rural megachurches , hmm, because life in a , hmm, because life in a , hmm, because life in a rural community is rural community is rural community is smaller. It is more smaller. It is more smaller. It is more segmented. In segmented. In segmented. In some cases it is some cases it is some cases it is less mobile. People less mobile. People less mobile. People just pray and just pray and just pray and play near their play near their play near their homes. Hmm homes. Hmm , it's not just three , it's not just three , it's not just three people, let people, let people, let me think about it. It is me think about it. It is me think about it. It is October. I can October. I can October. I can remember not only three remember not only three remember not only three people who came to people who came to people who came to faith in our community faith in our community faith in our community this year, but over the this year, but over the this year, but over the past 10 years I past 10 years I past 10 years I can remember almost can remember almost can remember almost everyone because of the size of everyone because of the size of everyone because of the size of our community. And all of our community. And all of our community. And all of these stories, all of these these stories, all of these these stories, all of these life changes, are life changes, are life changes, are probably probably probably represented in the represented in the represented in the overwhelming overwhelming overwhelming 88% of rural pastors 88% of rural pastors 88% of rural pastors who say, "Yes, I who say, "Yes, I who say, "Yes, I believe our community believe our community believe our community has become stronger over the has become stronger over the has become stronger over the past 10 years."
-
past 10 years." past 10 years." Because Because Because our community is so our community is so our community is so small and small and small and interconnected, I interconnected, I interconnected, I can recall the history of the can recall the history of the can recall the history of the last 10 years. And I, last 10 years. And I, last 10 years. And I, of course, have a lot of of course, have a lot of of course, have a lot of hope. I will be baptizing hope. I will be baptizing hope. I will be baptizing a family of three a family of three a family of three in a couple of weeks. There is, in a couple of weeks. There is, in a couple of weeks. There is, there is, there is a young woman who there is, there is a young woman who there is, there is a young woman who happened to come to happened to come to happened to come to our church because she our church because she our church because she did a Google search and did a Google search and did a Google search and found our church. found our church. found our church. And she goes to And she goes to And she goes to church every week. It church every week. It church every week. It transcends ordinary transcends ordinary transcends ordinary church members and their church members and their church-going habits. She is there church-going habits. She is there every week. She asks every week. She asks every week. She asks good questions. She good questions. She good questions. She prays for the first time. So prays for the first time. So prays for the first time. So I saw all these changes up close I saw all these changes up close I saw all these changes up close . And that gives . And that gives . And that gives me all the hope me all the hope me all the hope I have to answer I have to answer I have to answer if someone were to ask if someone were to ask if someone were to ask me this question, me this question, me this question, you know, uh, how do you... I'm you know, uh, how do you... I'm you know, uh, how do you... I'm not sure exactly not sure exactly not sure exactly how how how the question was asked, but something the question was asked, but something the question was asked, but something like, "Do like, "Do like, "Do you expect your you expect your you expect your church to be as church to be as church to be as strong in 10 strong in 10 strong in 10 years?" For me, that would be a years?" For me, that would be a years?" For me, that would be a resounding resounding yes, because all of these yes, because all of these yes, because all of these people are flesh and people are flesh and people are flesh and blood, and their blood, and their blood, and their life changes give me life changes give me life changes give me enough hope to enough hope to enough hope to look forward to the look forward to the look forward to the future. Another future. Another future. Another topic worth topic worth topic worth trying to trying to trying to answer is the answer is the answer is the question: "What question: "What question: "What defines the success defines the success defines the success of ministry for you?" And this of ministry for you?" And this of ministry for you?" And this question is critically question is critically question is critically important for important for important for understanding how you understanding how you understanding how you envision the envision the envision the next 10 years.
-
next 10 years. next 10 years. Hmm. Hmm. Hmm. 89% agreed that 89% agreed that 89% agreed that effective ministry effective ministry is more about being present is more about being present is more about being present in people's lives than about having in people's lives than about having in people's lives than about having good church good church good church programs. programs. programs. Hmm. Hmm. Hmm. We saw this a few We saw this a few We saw this a few weeks ago in an episode weeks ago in an episode where we talked about where we talked about where we talked about smaller churches smaller churches smaller churches versus larger ones. versus larger ones. versus larger ones. Yes. Yes. Yes. So, pastors were the So, pastors were the So, pastors were the most likely to identify most likely to identify most likely to identify their greatest their greatest their greatest personal personal personal evangelistic evangelistic evangelistic impact, which is important because impact, which is important because impact, which is important because that was 2 weeks ago that was 2 weeks ago that was 2 weeks ago when we were talking about when we were talking about when we were talking about how Christians how Christians how Christians share their faith. share their faith. share their faith. Well, in this report, Well, in this report, Well, in this report, pastors identified pastors identified pastors identified their greatest their greatest their greatest personal personal personal evangelistic evangelistic evangelistic impact as impact as impact as individual individual individual listening, listening, listening, being present during being present during being present during events in people's lives, events in people's lives, events in people's lives, and building and building and building friendships over meals friendships over meals friendships over meals and events. When I and events. When I and events. When I think of you, I think think of you, I think think of you, I think of a good listener of a good listener of a good listener because I realize because I realize because I realize how many conversations, how many conversations, how many conversations, professional and professional and professional and personal, where you're personal, where you're personal, where you're just sitting there and I'm like, just sitting there and I'm like, just sitting there and I'm like, "Okay, "Okay, "Okay, shut up for a second shut up for a second shut up for a second because I'm going to because I'm going to because I'm going to talk." And then you talk." And then you talk." And then you speak, and I know speak, and I know speak, and I know you can see that I'm you can see that I'm you can see that I'm ready to speak, and ready to speak, and ready to speak, and you say, "Can you say, "Can you say, "Can I just I just I just consider this thought?" consider this thought?" "And I say, 'But I have "And I say, 'But I have "And I say, 'But I have something else to say.'" something else to say.'" something else to say.'" Great listening. To be Great listening. To be Great listening. To be present in present in present in people's lives. Every weekend, people's lives. Every weekend, a picture of this a picture of this man is posted on Instagram and he says, man is posted on Instagram and he says, man is posted on Instagram and he says, "Oh, we're at some "Oh, we're at some "Oh, we're at some wedding." I'm like, "Who is wedding." I'm like, "Who is wedding." I'm like, "Who is this person?" I...And then this person?" I...And then this person?" I...And then I build friendships over I build friendships over I build friendships over dinners and other dinners and other dinners and other events. God, if events. God, if events. God, if not, if, if, if not, if, if, if not, if, if, if Alexander Mills doesn't Alexander Mills doesn't Alexander Mills doesn't love cooking, love cooking, love cooking, serving food, and eating.
-
serving food, and eating. In related interviews, In related interviews, one pastor one pastor one pastor talked about how talked about how talked about how he spent his morning he spent his morning he spent his morning every week at every week at every week at McDonald's. And that McDonald's. And that McDonald's. And that after 2 years, people after 2 years, people after 2 years, people knew where to find him knew where to find him knew where to find him and began to contact and began to contact and began to contact him with their him with their him with their questions and questions and questions and personal needs personal needs . And the reason I wrote this down is because . And the reason I wrote this down is because I remember the I remember the pastor at the pastor at the pastor at the McDonald's where McDonald's where McDonald's where my my my wife worked. And he wife worked. And he wife worked. And he was always there in the morning. And I was always there in the morning. And I was always there in the morning. And I remember thinking that remember thinking that remember thinking that my pastor, who was a my pastor, who was a my pastor, who was a youth pastor, was youth pastor, was youth pastor, was in the office, and this pastor in the office, and this pastor in the office, and this pastor was always here at was always here at was always here at McDonald's. And I McDonald's. And I McDonald's. And I thought about it because there thought about it because there was always this was always this group of people at McDonald's. And sometimes group of people at McDonald's. And sometimes group of people at McDonald's. And sometimes he sat with them, he sat with them, he sat with them, sometimes he read. And they were sometimes he read. And they were sometimes he read. And they were just hanging out. And just hanging out. And just hanging out. And you know, I'm a teenager in you know, I'm a teenager in you know, I'm a teenager in high school. I'm high school. I'm high school. I'm just trying to just trying to just trying to figure out my figure out my figure out my life. Spending a life. Spending a life. Spending a slow morning slow morning slow morning sipping coffee was sipping coffee was sipping coffee was n't exactly a way n't exactly a way n't exactly a way to imagine to imagine to imagine adulthood. And now, adulthood. And now, adulthood. And now, you know, I'm 35 now, you know, I'm 35 now, you know, I'm 35 now, I read about it and I I read about it and I I read about it and I realize that it's just about realize that it's just about realize that it's just about being available. I will being available. I will being available. I will never forget never forget never forget reading one of reading one of reading one of Bob Goff's books. I don't Bob Goff's books. I don't Bob Goff's books. I don't consider myself someone consider myself someone consider myself someone who has read that who has read that who has read that many of them. I remember many of them. I remember many of them. I remember one anecdote. And it one anecdote. And it one anecdote. And it might not even have been might not even have been might not even have been reading a book, reading a book, reading a book, maybe someone maybe someone maybe someone told me about it, told me about it, told me about it, for example, he put for example, he put for example, he put his phone number in the his phone number in the his phone number in the book, because his book, because his book, because his principle was: it principle was: it principle was: it doesn't matter who's doesn't matter who's doesn't matter who's calling me or who calling me or who calling me or who needs me at the needs me at the needs me at the moment, at that moment moment, at that moment moment, at that moment they're the most important. And they're the most important. And they're the most important. And I remember thinking that was the I remember thinking that was the stupidest thing stupidest thing I had ever I had ever I had ever heard. This doesn't make any heard. This doesn't make any heard. This doesn't make any sense. I do sense. I do sense. I do n't understand this at all. It was so n't understand this at all. It was so n't understand this at all. It was so offensive to love the
-
offensive to love the offensive to love the way I understood life that way I understood life that way I understood life that I couldn't get rid of I couldn't get rid of I couldn't get rid of it ever since I it ever since I it ever since I heard it for heard it for heard it for about 10 years. I about 10 years. I about 10 years. I don't practice this. I don't practice this. I don't practice this. I don't know if I believe it don't know if I believe it , but I know there's , but I know there's , but I know there's something about it that something about it that something about it that no matter no matter no matter what's happening in that what's happening in that what's happening in that moment, the person moment, the person moment, the person in front of me is the in front of me is the most important thing in the most important thing in the most important thing in the world. Like there's something world. Like there's something world. Like there's something I know is true. I do I know is true. I do I know is true. I do n't know how you give out n't know how you give out n't know how you give out your phone number your phone number your phone number and then find yourself and then find yourself and then find yourself available to them, let alone the available to them, let alone the people closest to you. I don't know. But I people closest to you. I don't know. But I just remember just remember just remember thinking, okay, there's thinking, okay, there's thinking, okay, there's something about the idea of something about the idea of something about the idea of accessibility, accessibility, accessibility, no matter what no matter what no matter what your your your calendar or life looks like. It calendar or life looks like. It calendar or life looks like. It matters, and here we matters, and here we matters, and here we see it when see it when see it when you show that you are what you show that you are what you show that you are what matters. matters. matters. Yes, my dad embodies Yes, my dad embodies Yes, my dad embodies that as a rural that as a rural that as a rural presence and pastor, presence and pastor, presence and pastor, and as I said and as I said and as I said before, as someone who before, as someone who before, as someone who has an identity that's sort of like has an identity that's sort of like has an identity that's sort of like Niagara, I Niagara, I Niagara, I can't tell you can't tell you can't tell you how many people he how many people he how many people he marries and buries marries and buries marries and buries in a year who are in a year who are in a year who are not connected not connected not connected to our church to our church to our church community at all. But community at all. But community at all. But because my father is because my father is because my father is well-known in Niagara, and well-known in Niagara, and well-known in Niagara, and he’s known as a pastor he’s known as a pastor he’s known as a pastor in Niagara, a trusted in Niagara, a trusted in Niagara, a trusted person in Niagara, person in Niagara, person in Niagara, his friends from high his friends from high his friends from high school say things school say things school say things like, “Hey, my mom’s like, “Hey, my mom’s like, “Hey, my mom’s dying. Can you dying. Can you dying. Can you go see her at the go see her at the go see her at the hospital? Or do these hospital? Or do these hospital? Or do these people just people just people just appear out of nowhere; appear out of nowhere; appear out of nowhere; but they have some but they have some but they have some connection to my connection to my connection to my father, whether from father, whether from father, whether from the past or the the past or the the past or the present, and they present, and they present, and they trust him as a trust him as a trust him as a spiritual guide spiritual guide , and he remains , and he remains , and he remains available to them. And I'm available to them. And I'm available to them. And I'm going to put your going to put your going to put your phone number in phone number in phone number in the description of this video the description of this video the description of this video so people can so people can so people can find you and you can find you and you can find you and you can really practice really practice really practice being available. So that's being available. So that's being available. So that's where they can where they can where they can find your
-
find your find your phone number. But yeah, it's phone number. But yeah, it's phone number. But yeah, it's just amazing just amazing just amazing to watch the to watch the to watch the rural community, and rural community, and rural community, and I can even I can even I can even compare and compare and compare and contrast my contrast my contrast my pastoral ministry pastoral ministry pastoral ministry with my father's because I with my father's because I with my father's because I don't live in Niagara-on-the- don't live in Niagara-on-the- Lake. I don't live where I Lake. I don't live where I Lake. I don't live where I was born. Maybe I'll was born. Maybe I'll was born. Maybe I'll come back someday. But come back someday. But come back someday. But I live in Niagara I live in Niagara I live in Niagara Falls, Falls, Falls, you live 5 minutes you live 5 minutes you live 5 minutes from here. from here. from here. Yes, but I live in Yes, but I live in Yes, but I live in Niagara Niagara Niagara Falls. I live as if Falls. I live as if Falls. I live as if the city where I live is the city where I live is the city where I live is much livelier. There are much livelier. There are much livelier. There are many more many more many more people there. You don't know people there. You don't know people there. You don't know where your where your where your child goes to school, do you child goes to school, do you child goes to school, do you ? So it's not just ? So it's not just ? So it's not just something like, "Hey, something like, "Hey, something like, "Hey, we live here. We are we live here. We are we live here. We are going to move. going to move. " We already have " We already have " We already have roots here, roots here, roots here, and a lot of our friends are and a lot of our friends are and a lot of our friends are here, but when you go here, but when you go here, but when you go to the grocery to the grocery to the grocery store, well, store, well, store, well, look around town, look around town, look around town, you can choose from a you can choose from a you can choose from a few few few dozen grocery dozen grocery dozen grocery stores. stores. stores. There is one in Niagara. So you know There is one in Niagara. So you know There is one in Niagara. So you know who owns the who owns the who owns the grocery grocery grocery store. You know store. You know store. You know who the cashier is at the who the cashier is at the who the cashier is at the grocery grocery grocery store. They know store. They know store. They know you. I don't have that kind of you. I don't have that kind of you. I don't have that kind of experience here. experience here. experience here. So when it So when it So when it comes to comes to comes to who I marry, and who I marry, and who I marry, and Barry, it's not people who Barry, it's not people who Barry, it's not people who know me from the city. know me from the city. know me from the city. These are mostly people from These are mostly people from These are mostly people from our church our church our church community. So I community. So I community. So I can even compare my can even compare my can even compare my pastoral relationship pastoral relationship pastoral relationship to my to my to my father's relationship. It is rural father's relationship. It is rural father's relationship. It is rural by definition. I am a by definition. I am a by definition. I am a pastor at a rural pastor at a rural pastor at a rural church, but my church, but my church, but my pastoral network is pastoral network is pastoral network is a little different a little different a little different from his.
-
from his. from his. Yes. Yeah, we live in Yes. Yeah, we live in Yes. Yeah, we live in Niagara-on-the-Lake City, Niagara-on-the-Lake City, Niagara-on-the-Lake City, and I remember when we and I remember when we and I remember when we moved there, moved there, moved there, driving out of driving out of driving out of Niagara Niagara Niagara Falls, I realized, Falls, I realized, "Oh, every time I "Oh, every time I "Oh, every time I go to the post office, I know a go to the post office, I know a go to the post office, I know a woman who works there woman who works there ." Only three people work there ." Only three people work there ." Only three people work there . So I go there and . So I go there and . So I go there and then they... then they... then they... Your post Your post Your post office is the size office is the size office is the size of this room. of this room. of this room. Yes. Oh, it's the best. Yes. Oh, it's the best. Yes. Oh, it's the best. And they are always cheerful. And they are always cheerful. And they are always cheerful. And then I see And then I see And then I see them walking their them walking their them walking their dogs. And we nod. dogs. And we nod. dogs. And we nod. We, you know, greet We, you know, greet We, you know, greet each other. each other. each other. I was recently at the I was recently at the I was recently at the playground playground playground with my daughter. And with my daughter. And with my daughter. And we recently returned from we recently returned from we recently returned from a trip to Africa. a trip to Africa. a trip to Africa. One of the countries we One of the countries we One of the countries we visited was visited was visited was South Africa. And 2 South Africa. And 2 South Africa. And 2 years ago I years ago I years ago I went to Australia for the first time. And I went to Australia for the first time. And I went to Australia for the first time. And I heard the accent of a heard the accent of a heard the accent of a mother whose children are mother whose children are mother whose children are about my age. about my age. about my age. And I thought, "Hey, I'm And I thought, "Hey, I'm And I thought, "Hey, I'm going to going to going to Australia soon." And she Australia soon." And she Australia soon." And she said, "I'm said, "I'm said, "I'm South African." South African." South African." And I said, "Yes." And I said, "Yes." And I said, "Yes." I'm very sorry. I'm very sorry. I'm very sorry. And I waited 2 years. And I And I waited 2 years. And I And I waited 2 years. And I saw her on the saw her on the saw her on the playground. playground. playground. And I said, "I won't And I said, "I won't And I said, "I won't mistake you for mistake you for mistake you for Australian again, but Australian again, but Australian again, but next time I'm going next time I'm going next time I'm going to South Africa." to South Africa." to South Africa." And she said, "Oh." And And she said, "Oh." And And she said, "Oh." And we started talking about it we started talking about it we started talking about it . And then . And then . And then she was a little less she was a little less she was a little less enthusiastic than I enthusiastic than I enthusiastic than I thought. And I don't know thought. And I don't know thought. And I don't know why she lives in why she lives in why she lives in Canada and not in Canada and not in Canada and not in South Africa, South Africa, South Africa, where she's from. Um, where she's from. Um, where she's from. Um, but I leaned over to my but I leaned over to my but I leaned over to my wife and said something wife and said something wife and said something like, “She’s from like, “She’s from like, “She’s from South Africa. " South Africa. " South Africa. " Where did I get this from?"
-
Where did I get this from?" Where did I get this from?" I thought she was from I thought she was from I thought she was from New Zealand. New Zealand. New Zealand. That's what I said. I That's what I said. I That's what I said. I thought, “If she’s a thought, “If she’s a thought, “If she’s a Kiwi, then no, that was Kiwi, then no, that was Kiwi, then no, that was last year. I last year. I last year. I missed that. I missed that. I missed that. I missed that. “Your missed that. “Your missed that. “Your city remembers” is what city remembers” is what city remembers” is what Alex is Alex is Alex is hinting at here. And that hinting at here. And that hinting at here. And that was also included in was also included in was also included in this study. 88% this study. 88% consider consider consider community trust a sign of community trust a sign of community trust a sign of ministry success. ministry success. ministry success. Yes. Is that what Yes. Is that what Yes. Is that what you would think of, you would think of, you would think of, like, a like, a like, a megachurch, a pastor, megachurch, a pastor, megachurch, a pastor, yes, a church that is yes, a church that is yes, a church that is trusted by the community, trusted by the community, trusted by the community, certainly, but not in the certainly, but not in the certainly, but not in the same vein that I same vein that I same vein that I imagine that describes. imagine that describes. imagine that describes. And what was also And what was also And what was also interesting was that 25 interesting was that 25 % of the people, the pastors in this % of the people, the pastors in this % of the people, the pastors in this article, said that article, said that article, said that the lack of trust in the congregation the lack of trust in the congregation the lack of trust in the congregation was a problem that was a problem that was a problem that arose from the arose from the church's past mistakes. church's past mistakes. Interesting. Interesting. Interesting. Yes, one pastor there Yes, one pastor there Yes, one pastor there said that it took said that it took him him about about about eight years to be accepted by the community. An eight years to be accepted by the community. An eight years to be accepted by the community. An individual individual individual experience, not average, experience, not average, experience, not average, because the because the because the church's reputation preceded church's reputation preceded church's reputation preceded it. So he it. So he it. So he had to work for had to work for had to work for eight years before eight years before eight years before that changed and people that changed and people that changed and people started trusting him started trusting him started trusting him and the church in a new way. And this is and the church in a new way. And this is and the church in a new way. And this is where keeping where keeping where keeping that little that little that little promise can matter promise can matter promise can matter more than more than more than churches realize, churches realize, churches realize, because when you are because when you are because when you are such a close-knit such a close-knit such a close-knit community, it's a different thing community, it's a different thing community, it's a different thing about rural about rural about rural churches. The news churches. The news churches. The news spreads quickly in spreads quickly in spreads quickly in the community and in the church.
-
the community and in the church. the community and in the church. So the question is So the question is So the question is , how would people who have , how would people who have , how would people who have never never never attended describe attended describe attended describe our church? Alex our church? Alex our church? Alex describes that if people describes that if people describes that if people have enough have enough have enough trust to say, trust to say, trust to say, when my family is when my family is when my family is going through the worst going through the worst going through the worst moment, someone is sick moment, someone is sick moment, someone is sick in the hospital, then this is the in the hospital, then this is the in the hospital, then this is the church I church I church I turn to. Or when turn to. Or when turn to. Or when we are ready to celebrate a we are ready to celebrate a we are ready to celebrate a marriage as a family, it is the marriage as a family, it is the marriage as a family, it is the pastor we pastor we pastor we ask to perform the ask to perform the ask to perform the wedding. This speaks wedding. This speaks wedding. This speaks to the trust they to the trust they to the trust they have in this church have in this church have in this church and its leadership. and its leadership. and its leadership. And the last thing I And the last thing I And the last thing I want to talk about want to talk about want to talk about before we do before we do before we do one simple exercise to one simple exercise to one simple exercise to end this end this end this episode is what episode is what episode is what we don't want to do we don't want to do we don't want to do is romanticize the is romanticize the is romanticize the struggle in this struggle in this struggle in this episode. The fact that 88% of episode. The fact that 88% of rural pastors rural pastors rural pastors had hope for the had hope for the had hope for the next decade next decade in no way in no way in no way diminishes the challenges, diminishes the challenges, diminishes the challenges, especially in this especially in this especially in this economy. We've economy. We've economy. We've noticed this year, noticed this year, noticed this year, even in some of the even in some of the even in some of the campaigns that we've campaigns that we've campaigns that we've run and the run and the run and the emails emails emails that I've gotten back and forth that I've gotten back and forth with churches, with churches, with churches, just saying, "Oh, just saying, "Oh, just saying, "Oh, you know, usually it is, you know, usually it is, you know, usually it is, but right now because of what but right now because of what but right now because of what I've heard over and over again I've heard over and over again I've heard over and over again about about about budget freezes, this economy budget freezes, this economy , spending cuts, , spending cuts, , spending cuts, just all the things that just all the things that just all the things that churches are doing." So churches are doing." So churches are doing." So I hear about it. This I hear about it. This I hear about it. This was also evident in this was also evident in this was also evident in this data among pastors of data among pastors of data among pastors of churches with churches with churches with attendances of less than 50 attendances of less than 50 attendances of less than 50 people. 24% disagreed people. 24% disagreed people. 24% disagreed that their church would be that their church would be that their church would be stronger in 10 stronger in 10 stronger in 10 years. So, specifically years. So, specifically years. So, specifically for rural churches for rural churches for rural churches that had fewer than that had fewer than that had fewer than 50 people, you see that 88 50 people, you see that 88 % are not sure it % are not sure it % are not sure it will be stronger will be stronger will be stronger in a decade, 24% - in a decade, 24% - no, it won't.
-
no, it won't. no, it won't. Of course, there is some kind of Of course, there is some kind of Of course, there is some kind of inflection point inflection point inflection point regarding the size of regarding the size of regarding the size of the community. I don't know, I don't the community. I don't know, I don't the community. I don't know, I don't know what it is. You know what it is. You know what it is. You can... I can... I can... I mean you mean you mean you start to see it start to see it start to see it here, with 50 compared to the here, with 50 compared to the here, with 50 compared to the total total ... Hmm, but certainly ... Hmm, but certainly ... Hmm, but certainly when a congregation gets to a when a congregation gets to a when a congregation gets to a certain size, a certain size, a certain size, a small size, small size, small size, whether it's 50 or 40 or I, I whether it's 50 or 40 or I, I whether it's 50 or 40 or I, I don't know what it is, don't know what it is, don't know what it is, somewhere around there, the somewhere around there, the somewhere around there, the longevity of the longevity of the longevity of the congregation certainly congregation certainly congregation certainly starts to seem starts to seem starts to seem a lot more fragile... I a lot more fragile... I a lot more fragile... I wonder wonder wonder than, say, the than, say, the than, say, the average average average church size in America is 65 or church size in America is 65 or church size in America is 65 or 75. Anywhere below that it starts to 75. Anywhere below that it starts to 75. Anywhere below that it starts to seem very, very seem very, very seem very, very uncertain. That's uncertain. That's uncertain. That's right. right. right. And in this sample, 40% And in this sample, 40% showed exhaustion showed exhaustion showed exhaustion from over- from over- from over- commitment, commitment, commitment, overwork, 20% - 6% - overwork, 20% - 6% - burnout, 26% - burnout, 26% - loneliness. So we don't loneliness. So we don't loneliness. So we don't want to just want to just want to just say that say that say that everything is rosy, because that's everything is rosy, because that's everything is rosy, because that's not true, despite the not true, despite the not true, despite the overall overall overall encouraging picture. A encouraging picture. A encouraging picture. A simple exercise. I simple exercise. I simple exercise. I like to look at 10- like to look at 10- year time year time year time horizons. If you horizons. If you horizons. If you go into my go into my go into my home office, home office, home office, I have a wall with a chalkboard on it, I have a wall with a chalkboard on it, I have a wall with a chalkboard on it, and for years I wrote on and for years I wrote on and for years I wrote on that wall, "You that wall, "You that wall, "You overestimate what you overestimate what you overestimate what you can accomplish in 1 can accomplish in 1 can accomplish in 1 year, you underestimate year, you underestimate year, you underestimate what you can what you can what you can accomplish in 10." And so accomplish in 10." And so accomplish in 10." And so maybe one of the maybe one of the maybe one of the reasons I was reasons I was reasons I was drawn to this drawn to this drawn to this initial report, and it was initial report, and it was initial report, and it was exactly 10 years out, exactly 10 years out, exactly 10 years out, was that I thought, was that I thought, was that I thought, "I like to think about 10- "I like to think about 10- year time year time year time horizons because horizons because horizons because anything seems anything seems anything seems possible on a 10-year possible on a 10-year possible on a 10-year horizon." So I horizon." So I horizon." So I think it's useful.
-
think it's useful. think it's useful. Churches of any Churches of any Churches of any size, write down size, write down size, write down your definition of what your definition of what “ 10 years stronger” means to you and your church 10 years stronger” means to you and your church . We talked about . We talked about . We talked about what was highlighted in what was highlighted in what was highlighted in this particular this particular this particular report, what exactly report, what exactly report, what exactly was being asked of was being asked of was being asked of pastors, but pastors, but pastors, but consider for yourself consider for yourself consider for yourself the depth of leadership, the depth of leadership, the depth of leadership, discipleship, relationships, discipleship, relationships, discipleship, relationships, just presence in just presence in just presence in people's lives, the trust of the people's lives, the trust of the people's lives, the trust of the community, financial community, financial community, financial stability, stability, stability, pastoral health pastoral health pastoral health for you. Where the shape of for you. Where the shape of for you. Where the shape of your church your church your church looks the same, looks the same, looks the same, but maybe you are not but maybe you are not but maybe you are not alone, you are not alone, you are not alone, you are not burned out, you are not burned out, you are not burned out, you are not exhausted. This would be a exhausted. This would be a exhausted. This would be a huge step huge step huge step forward because it forward because it forward because it means your means your means your church would be in a church would be in a church would be in a healthier state healthier state healthier state if it didn't demand if it didn't demand if it didn't demand so much from you, so much from you, so much from you, or if you didn't believe or if you didn't believe or if you didn't believe it needed it needed it needed so much from you. so much from you. so much from you. Choose three Choose three Choose three outcomes. I always outcomes. I always outcomes. I always like them to be like them to be like them to be as tangible as possible as tangible as possible . And then take it . And then take it . And then take it from 10 years, reduce it. from 10 years, reduce it. from 10 years, reduce it. Describe what Describe what Describe what realistic, realistic, realistic, measurable progress would be measurable progress would be measurable progress would be over those 12 over those 12 over those 12 months. And then months. And then months. And then go back a year go back a year go back a year and set a new and set a new and set a new 10-year goal. 10-year goal. 10-year goal. Final thoughts from a Final thoughts from a Final thoughts from a village village village reverend?
-
reverend? I think my final I think my final thoughts will come right thoughts will come right thoughts will come right after this exercise, after this exercise, after this exercise, which is that which is that which is that stronger communities are stronger communities are stronger communities are unlikely unlikely unlikely to happen to happen to happen by chance. It seems like by chance. It seems like by chance. It seems like the Lord's work, doesn't the Lord's work, doesn't the Lord's work, doesn't it? As God brings it? As God brings it? As God brings growth, so God growth, so God growth, so God brings the church. brings the church. brings the church. Let's just Let's just Let's just say that this is our say that this is our say that this is our fundamental agreement, fundamental agreement, fundamental agreement, absolutely. But when it absolutely. But when it absolutely. But when it comes to comes to comes to pastoral pastoral pastoral health, discipleship health, discipleship health, discipleship or relationships, or relationships, or relationships, financial financial financial stability, these stability, these stability, these things don't... They don't things don't... They don't things don't... They don't happen by accident happen by accident . They happen . They happen . They happen intentionally, or, if intentionally, or, if intentionally, or, if neglected, they don't neglected, they don't neglected, they don't happen...They happen...They happen...They probably don't happen at all probably don't happen at all probably don't happen at all . And because it . And because it . And because it is in itself a is in itself a is in itself a purposeful purposeful purposeful act. act. act. That's right. That's right. That's right. That's right. That's right. That's right. So, we can have So, we can have So, we can have hope that our hope that our hope that our communities will become communities will become communities will become stronger through stronger through stronger through things. And hope is things. And hope is things. And hope is good. Hope is what good. Hope is what good. Hope is what gets us out of gets us out of gets us out of bed and gives us the bed and gives us the bed and gives us the courage to do courage to do courage to do anything. But this anything. But this anything. But this exercise is mandatory exercise is mandatory . Because to be a . Because to be a . Because to be a stronger, uh, stronger, uh, stronger, uh, community, just like community, just like community, just like being a stronger body, being a stronger body, being a stronger body, like a physical like a physical like a physical body, you can body, you can body, you can want to be strong, want to be strong, want to be strong, you can have hope you can have hope you can have hope that, like, in 10 that, like, in 10 that, like, in 10 years I'll be years I'll be years I'll be stronger than I am stronger than I am stronger than I am today, but it's today, but it's today, but it's going to take work. I going to take work. I going to take work. I have to do an have to do an have to do an exercise. I have to exercise. I have to exercise. I have to lift heavy things.
-
lift heavy things. lift heavy things. We can have all the We can have all the We can have all the hope in the world. Perhaps hope in the world. Perhaps hope in the world. Perhaps 100% of rural pastors 100% of rural pastors 100% of rural pastors say, "I hope say, "I hope say, "I hope my congregation will be my congregation will be my congregation will be stronger in 10 stronger in 10 stronger in 10 years." But we years." But we years." But we must accept, must accept, must accept, first define, and first define, and first define, and then accept then accept then accept the responsibility the responsibility the responsibility to do the work; to do the work; to do the work; to do things that to do things that to do things that will help strengthen will help strengthen will help strengthen our community, both the our community, both the our community, both the leaders of our community, the leaders of our community, the leaders of our community, the pastors (we pastors (we pastors (we talked a lot about talked a lot about talked a lot about rural pastors today), and rural pastors today), and rural pastors today), and the people who the people who the people who make up our make up our make up our community: people who, um, are community: people who, um, are community: people who, um, are maturing in their maturing in their maturing in their faith, people who are faith, people who are faith, people who are coming to the Lord, coming to the Lord, coming to the Lord, um, again and again. Um, um, again and again. Um, um, again and again. Um, we have to accept we have to accept we have to accept our our our responsibility there responsibility there , do the work , do the work , do the work to see what we to see what we to see what we hope hope hope to see, which is to see, which is to see, which is stronger communities, but stronger communities, but stronger communities, but it will take work. it will take work. it will take work. And to all who serve in the And to all who serve in the And to all who serve in the village church, we are village church, we are village church, we are so grateful for your so grateful for your so grateful for your efforts, and we know efforts, and we know efforts, and we know they are not in vain. And they are not in vain. And they are not in vain. And just keep going in the just keep going in the just keep going in the same vein, even same vein, even same vein, even when you don't get when you don't get when you don't get as much visibility, as much visibility, as much visibility, airtime, airtime, airtime, coverage, coverage, coverage, exposure or attention exposure or attention exposure or attention as other churches, we as other churches, we as other churches, we hope that hope that hope that even this little even this little even this little episode will encourage episode will encourage episode will encourage everyone who serves in everyone who serves in everyone who serves in churches, because we know churches, because we know churches, because we know that's most that's most that's most churches and most churches and most churches and most people who serve in people who serve in people who serve in leadership positions.
-
leadership positions. leadership positions. Thank you for your time, Thank you for your time, Thank you for your time, your attention, your your attention, your your attention, your service, and your service, and your service, and your trust. We'll talk trust. We'll talk trust. We'll talk to you next to you next to you next week. Parents are almost week. Parents are almost week. Parents are almost twice as likely twice as likely twice as likely to get married. Parents. to get married. Parents. Pastors are almost twice as Pastors are almost twice as likely...
Summary
This episode of the Pro Church Tools Show explores a surprising Lifeway survey revealing that 88 percent of rural pastors expect their churches to become stronger within a decade. The discussion centers on the data findings, the unique challenges of small and village ministry, and the nuances of how rural communities are defined. The practical takeaway is that despite the perceived difficulties of working in small rural settings, church leaders possess a high level of resilience and long-term optimism for growth.